Aberdeen’s Collapsing Economy Shows the True Cost of Net Zero

Property prices plummeting 37%, job’s haemorrhaging 1,000 a month, an economy in freefall – the tragedy of UK oil capital Aberdeen shows the true cost of Net Zero and the failure of Ed Miliband’s ‘energy transition’, says Benedict Smith in the Telegraph. Here’s an excerpt.

Just over a decade ago, Aberdeen was thriving.

It was the gateway to Britain’s North Sea oil and gas industry. Average weekly earnings were higher only in London and it consistently ranked among the top UK cities for business and jobs growth.

At £215,000, property prices were nearly double the Scottish average, having risen 165% in just 10 years as the area boomed.

Following the scent of oil and gas, new arrivals appeared in their droves to fill highly paid positions. Between 2004 and 2015, the population jumped by nearly 20,000 and local businesses flourished.

The picture is starkly different today. Tumbling oil prices, punitive taxes and the underwhelming advance of renewables have tipped the North Sea energy industry into a spiral of accelerated decline that is taking Aberdeen’s property market down with it.

Energy Secretary Ed Miliband’s pledge to deliver a Net Zero transition for the area – in which jobs in oil and gas are replaced by ones in clean energy – has also fallen flat.

Rather than a renewables energy boom, some of the biggest companies in the region have scaled back investment or withdrawn entirely, seeking more profitable opportunities in other places as far-flung as the Persian Gulf.

Many of the most skilled workers have gone with them.

Around 18,000 jobs have disappeared from Aberdeen since 2010. Without intervention, the local economy will lose the equivalent of 1,000 workers a month between now and 2030, according to trade association Offshore Energies UK.

As more people flee the region, homeowners in Aberdeen watch with a mixture of anger and dismay as the value of their homes sinks while a glut of properties hits the market.

More than two thirds of homes in Aberdeen fell in value last year, according to Zoopla. The average home now sells for just £136,000 – the lowest price since 2006.

At the same time, many have found their livelihoods hit by the energy sector’s declining activity. Falling profits at some of the region’s biggest employers have left residents directly employed in oil and gas, who account for more than one in 10 locals, at risk of losing their jobs. Many more in adjacent roles face the same fate.

Some of those who bought at the peak of the housing market in 2014 have taken house price hits as high as £90,000, blasting a hole in retirement plans. By contrast, UK house prices have risen on average by more than 53% since 2014.

Worth reading in full.

Subscribe
Notify of

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

18 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Solentviews
Solentviews
1 month ago

Mad Miliband is a major factor. However, it sounds like the downturn started around 2015. A decade of Tory failure right there. Never forgive, never forget.

Bill Bailey
Bill Bailey
1 month ago
Reply to  Solentviews

Yes the Tories were bad but Labour kicked it all off. “The original Climate Change Act, passed in 2008, set a legally binding target to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by at least 80% by 2050 compared to 1990 levels. This laid the foundational legal framework for climate action, including carbon budgets and promoting low-carbon (green/renewable) energy transitions”.

So they are both in the doghouse.

transmissionofflame
1 month ago
Reply to  Bill Bailey

Only 5 MPs voted against

pjar
1 month ago

How many were there?

As I recall, the whole thing was cooked up and passed through practically without any scrutiny at all?

Solentviews
Solentviews
1 month ago
Reply to  Bill Bailey

Of course the SNP are into Net Zero as well. I wonder if this will register with the inhabitants of Aberdeen in May. It will be very interesting to see who they vote for.

Gezza England
Gezza England
1 month ago
Reply to  Solentviews

Well if they continue to vote for the SNP, Labour or the Greens then we can just laugh at their decline.

john1T
1 month ago
Reply to  Solentviews

It’s not failure, at least not for TPTB. Deindustrialisation is policy, has been for decades. They don’t give a stuff about us.

iconoclast
1 month ago
Reply to  Solentviews

Never forgive, never forget.

JohnnyDownes
1 month ago

Even on its own terms, even if you agree that the pursuit of net zero emissions is a good thing, the mothballing of the North Sea oil industry is incredibly stupid.
It’s only supposed to be NET zero, not ABSOLUTE zero. There is no reason to suppose that we will not continue to use oil and gas, and it follows that we should be exploiting our oil reserves to our economic benefit in substitution for imports. We are governed by morons.

transmissionofflame
1 month ago
Reply to  JohnnyDownes

Indeed and oil is used in a lot of things essential to how we live, beyond energy

pjar
1 month ago
Reply to  JohnnyDownes

I know someone involved in the mothballing… his view is that it isn’t coming back, at least not by just re-opening the valves, so to speak.

The tech involved, and the required safety standards alone, means it will all have to be built again, from scratch, if we change our minds even in the near future.

nige.oldfart
1 month ago
Reply to  pjar

Thats the main problem with shutting stuff down, the cost of getting it going again is usually greater than a new installation. Moth balling industry is a false view, it is better to start again; if you can.

varmint
1 month ago
Reply to  JohnnyDownes

When Ideology trumps common sense this is what you get. —–ABSURDITY. —But because of all the climate change propaganda on our TV screens very few people realise they are being had.

EppingBlogger
1 month ago

This posting must be wrong. Miliband repeatedly tells us hydrocarbon proved are high and so windmills are cheaper.

sskinner
1 month ago

Well done Labour. Well F***** done.

Westfieldmike
Westfieldmike
1 month ago

You get what you vote for.

varmint
1 month ago

The biggest phoney planet savers are actually the SNP. They pretend to save the planet with a zeal that even MIliband wishes he had. yet Scots continue to vote for this bunch of charlatans. There is an old saying that “The people get the politicians they deserve” —-Although in Aberdeenshire I believe they vote Lib Dem, but they are almost as bad when it comes to climate politics. ——Wake up people there is NO CLIMATE CRISIS. You are being fleeced and impoverished under false pretences.

RTSC
RTSC
1 month ago

I’m sure the destruction of Aberdeen must be Thatcher’s fault.