Starmer Abolishes NHS England

Keir Starmer dramatically abolished NHS England today, with Ministers branding it “the world’s largest quango”, as he launched an assault on the “flabby, unfocused and over-cautious” state. The Mail has more.

The PM used a speech to deliver a damning verdict on the performance of the public sector, saying huge expansion in numbers had not worked.

He announced that NHS England will be abolished altogether, saying it would bring health provision back under “democratic control”.

Health Secretary Wes Streeting had already declared he would dramatically curb the body – which ministers have labelled the “world’s largest quango”. 

NHS England is the central bureaucracy that controls more than £190 billion a year of funding for health and has 15,000 staff. 

Its functions will be taken over by the Department of Health over the next two years, with headcount cut by 9,000 – although it is not clear how many of those will be deployed elsewhere.

Mr Streeting said there would be “hundreds of millions of pounds” of savings. 

The NHS England Chief Executive and National Medical Director both resigned in recent weeks as the scale of the overhaul became clear. 

It effectively reverses a huge reorganisation pushed through under the Coalition. It was welcomed by Tories including Jeremy Hunt, although he pointed out that Mr Streeting previously ruled out “top down reorganisation”.

NHS bosses voiced caution, saying there will be “disruption” and patient care must be “prioritised”. 

Sir Keir told the audience in Hull that Government was employing “more people than we’ve employed for decades”.

“Yet look around the country, do you see good value everywhere? Because I don’t,” he said. “I actually think it’s weaker than it’s ever been.”

Sir Keir said he believed in “active government” but that did not mean it should be “bigger”.

While being careful to praise civil servants, Sir Keir complained that Whitehall in general has not managed to improve frontline services.

However, the intervention has already drawn a furious response from unions who branded it “unrealistic” and insulting. Ministers have been playing down suggestions of wide scale jobs cuts, arguing that efficiency is the real goal.

No 10 has been forced to deny that the initiative has been nicknamed ‘Project Chainsaw’ internally.

Downing Street said the reference to Trump adviser Elon Musk wielding a chainsaw to represent his cuts to government spending was “juvenile”.

Sir Keir said abolishing NHS England will reduce “duplication”, saving money that can then be spent on frontline services.

Answering a question from a cancer patient on how the decision would improve the situation, the premier said: “Amongst the reasons we are abolishing it is because of the duplication.

“So, if you can believe it, we’ve got a communications team in NHS England, we’ve got a communications team in the health department of government; we’ve got a strategy team in NHS England, a strategy team in the government department. We are duplicating things that could be done once.

“If we strip that out, which is what we are doing today, that then allows us to free up that money to put it where it needs to be, which is the front line.”

He added that the Government wanted to push power to frontline workers “and away from the bureaucracy which often holds them up”.

In a statement, Mr Streeting said: “This is the final nail in the coffin of the disastrous 2012 reorganisation, which led to the longest waiting times, lowest patient satisfaction, and most expensive NHS in history.”

How will it save hundreds of millions if all the overpaid quangocrats keep their jobs and are just moved elsewhere? Something doesn’t add up here.

Worth reading in full.

Subscribe
Notify of

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

32 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
mrbu
mrbu
1 year ago

I’m happy to see a reduction in the bloated management strata of the health service. The next thing I’d like to see on my next visit to hospital is a reduction in the number of uniformed staff sitting around playing on their phones, chatting, or wandering aimlessly around corridors.

Sceptical Steve
Sceptical Steve
1 year ago
Reply to  mrbu

I thought they’d already sorted that problem by encouraging the staff to play with their phones at home. It was certainly the case in my wife’s department at our local hospital trust. Actually turning up for work at the hospital was reserved for the most junior staff.

huxleypiggles
1 year ago

😀😀😀

Cotfordtags
1 year ago

I think the first thing we can be absolutely sure of is that no civil servants will lose their job, they will be reallocated as Labour will never upset their paymasters in that way. I remember a big reorganization in the early eighties and knew a civil servant in the NHS whose job disappeared but he went straight into another that still enabled him to manage his retail business and rental properties at the same time. I also don’t understand why it is NHS England going rather than the Department for Health itself. Healthcare is devolved so why is England managed centrally while Scotland and Wales are not?

Jack the dog
Jack the dog
1 year ago
Reply to  Cotfordtags

What a tosser.

But I think it shows they’re running scared.

RTSC
RTSC
1 year ago
Reply to  Cotfordtags

I was a CS when the Coalition Government was elected. A few years later I was no longer a CS, instead I was transferred to another organisation which wasn’t within the CS but was funded by the Government and my terms and conditions of employment were unchanged.

The Coalition Government claimed that they had reduced the CS headcount. It was all smoke and mirrors …. as it will be this time.

Tonka Rigger
1 year ago

Find those in the system who add no value and provide no essential service and chop them. A public health body cannot afford to carry dead weight which saps funding.

At the same time, stop providing services to all and sundry, review procurement contracts and dispense with wastage like woke “training” and idiotic court cases persecuting women who don’t want to see John Thomases in the changing rooms. The law is clear.

JohnK
1 year ago

Perhaps he’s been reading the agenda written by one of the suspects across the pond? British DOGE, perhaps? However, reorganising something is bound to come with a load of upfront costs while it is worked through. Already, trade union disputes have been reported in the press, so we’ll learn how they resolve that lot.

modularist
1 year ago
Reply to  JohnK

Musk intends to augment or replace sections of the blob and deep state with AI, and the same plan is afoot here, likely with the same technology that we will buy from the US. One imagines Palantir will expand even further.

transmissionofflame
1 year ago

He announced that NHS England will be abolished altogether, saying it would bring health provision back under “democratic control”.”

Er, surely the taxpayer funded NHS is already under democratic control. Isn’t that the point?

“Its functions will be taken over by the Department of Health over the next two years, with headcount cut by 9,000 – although it is not clear how many of those will be deployed elsewhere.”

I will buy every regular commenter here a box of smarties if a single job is lost.

No 10 has been forced to deny that the initiative has been nicknamed ‘Project Chainsaw’ internally.
Downing Street said the reference to Trump adviser Elon Musk wielding a chainsaw to represent his cuts to government spending was “juvenile”.”

It was Milei who used the chainsaw first. Musk might have done too but it would have been as a hommage to Milei. I suspect most Labour people have no idea who Milei is or what he’s up to, though Starmer ought to since Milei gave the WEF people a good old bollocking at some meeting of theirs.

JohnK
1 year ago

Wasn’t aware of his position, but no shortage of critical stores about him, e.g. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5y86vv0wneo Look who’s with him in the image!

transmissionofflame
1 year ago
Reply to  JohnK

No chainsaw in this one but a good short summary of his plans: ¿Qué ministerios planea eliminar Milei si llega a la presidencia? Put subtitles on and set to auto-translate.

Arborvitae23
1 year ago

Don’t think I’ll be getting my smarties any time soon 😉

transmissionofflame
1 year ago
Reply to  Arborvitae23

I feel my money is safe. Smarties are bad for you anyway, and will probably be banned soon, or you can only buy black ones or something. No white or blue smarties, just brown, black, green and rainbow.

RW
RW
1 year ago

“He announced that NHS England will be abolished altogether, saying it would bring health provision back under “democratic control”.”
Er, surely the taxpayer funded NHS is already under democratic control. Isn’t that the point?

The department of health is part of the government, NHS England isn’t/ wasn’t. Assuming the civil service works (or worked) as it should, the political head of the DoH can give orders to DoH employees but couldn’t give orders to NHS England employees.

transmissionofflame
1 year ago
Reply to  RW

Who appoints the Chair and CEO of NHS England? Who do they report to? Where do they get their money from?

RW
RW
1 year ago

As far as I could determine, the secretary of state for health appoints the chair of the NHS England board and at least 5 non-executive members. All executive members are appointed by the non-executive members. A person can only become CEO of NHS England with consent of the SOSFH. The complete board then leads NHS England exactly as if it was a private company controlled by it, ie, without the SOSFH having any direct influence on that. The SOSFH may also unappoint non-executive members due to incapacity, misbehaviour or failure to do their duties.

https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/nhs-standing-orders-23-january-2025.pdf

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/41/schedule/A1/2022-07-01

CircusSpot
CircusSpot
1 year ago

I heard 2TK droning on as I sat in the GP Surgery awaiting an annual review. When he spoke the nonsense that A1 would save the NHS, my blood pressure reached new heights, especially as the very simple computer screen check in system in the Surgery was not working again.
When I discussed the 2TK speech with the young nurse she went even more crazy than I had.
Just put the medical staff and patients back in charge and the Health Service can be run better at less cost.

bertieboy
bertieboy
1 year ago

Happy to see a quango ‘bonfired’. However, saw what you did there KS. Gesture after reading the room.
How about a serious go through the lot a’la DOGE.

Art Simtotic
1 year ago

As a matter of interest, how many NHS England DIE officers will become surplus to NHS overall requirements?

huxleypiggles
1 year ago
Reply to  Art Simtotic

None. They will be given new job titles.

huxleypiggles
1 year ago

Whilst appreciating that Kneel is searching for headlines we should all understand by now that he only uses Newspeak. In other words whatever he says has to be interpreted literally or inverted. Abolishing NHS England means only that the title is being abolished and not any jobs. NHS England will be given a new grandiose banner and those receiving salaries – I didn’t want to say ‘working’ – will be given shiny new job titles. Let us remember Kneel’s mob were “elected” on a platform promising change. Any change will do even if it is name only. The reality is that the whole exercise will require hundreds of consultants and millions of pounds will be spaffed away in achieving absolutely nothing of any value except a poorer country, which is really all that Kneel is instructed to achieve.

Jack the dog
Jack the dog
1 year ago
Reply to  huxleypiggles

Quite right.

klf
klf
1 year ago

I’ll believe it when I see it.

Arborvitae23
1 year ago
Reply to  klf

And when the people I know working for NHS England haven’t been re-hired elsewhere in the Public Sector. Probably on increased salaries or as “consultants”.

JOpenmind
JOpenmind
1 year ago

Not sure he is getting rid of the right bit of the NHS. Basically every NHS location has a back office function and instead of having separate ones eg Procurement, there is benefit to having it centralised to reduce the duplication of effort. I thought NHS England was meant to be leading this but it never had the traction. So basically getting rid of it was not the best approach as we now have ongoing little fiefdoms.

JXB
JXB
1 year ago

I got excited – thought it referred to the ghastly bang-pans Stalin-era Leviathan “delivering” healthcare via our saintly and angelic doctors and nurses and what is needed to justify the need to bring in immigrants to run it.

Alas not.

bertieboy
bertieboy
1 year ago

‘Sir Keir said he believed in “active government” but that did not mean it should be “bigger”’’

So he doesn’t believe in “bigger” government. And there was me thinking that as a Trilateral he would consider democracy a problem!

DiscoveredJoys
DiscoveredJoys
1 year ago

The Conservatives turned into Labour and lost hugely at the last General Election, and Labour are now turning into Conservatives – although whether they carry their traditional supporters with them remains to be seen.

In the USA the Republicans now court the working man and the Democrats support the ‘Establishment’.

We live in interesting times, even if no QUANGOs are harmed in this policy change.

Gezza England
Gezza England
1 year ago

You can see Two Tier means business as he has his shirt sleeves rolled up and no tie. LOL! What a twat. I feel sorry for those ordered to stand behind the robot while he drones on, especially as they could be doing their jobs. And why is Two Tier making this statement and not Streeting as he is the health minister?

Bettina
Bettina
1 year ago

“as he launched an assault on the “flabby, unfocused and over-cautious” state”
……of himself? That waistline looks like he’s been eating too many dinners at the taxpayers’ expense.

RTSC
RTSC
1 year ago

I expect the re-branding and redundancy/re-hire of the 6-figure salary parasites will cost more than “abolition” will ever save.