Woke to the Bones? Pittsburgh Prof Denies Differences Between Male and Female Skeletons

The abrupt “No” drew guffaws of laughter from the audience at the University of Pittsburgh. Professor Gabby Yearwood, an anthropologist, was responding to a question posed by one Riley Gaines, a former female collegiate swimmer and outspoken defender of the sex binary. Gaines asked, “If you were to dig up a human – two humans – a hundred years from now, both a man and a woman, could you tell the difference strictly off of bones?”

It is unclear when the video was shot, but the tweet that sent it viral has now been viewed more than 1.4 million times. A variety of commentators have chimed in, many of them challenging Yearwood for the refusal to acknowledge biological sex differences and a lack of nuance. Some criticised the academic for making claims of credentialism to silence opposition. At one point during the video, the lecturer in the Department of Anthropology declared, “I have a PhD!”

The New York Post has the story.

“This is how far removed the Left is from reality that they must deny basic scientific facts,” tweeted the Independent Women’s Forum, a non-profit focused on economic policy issues.

“When the self-proclaimed “expert in the room” is offended that his assertion that males & females don’t have distinct skeletal differences is laughable, one might wonder what students studying anthropology at the University of Pittsburgh are being taught by their professors,” the group added.

Dr. Aisha El Ait Mohr tweeted, “That professor should resign immediately” – while another critic blasted, “back to school for that professor.”

Archeologists rely heavily on pelvis shape to determine the sex of a skeleton along with the general assumption that larger traits are male, including skulls and sizable areas where muscles attach to bone.

But archeologists have admitted mistakes in overlooking intersex individuals, along with small-statured men or large-statured women, according to Discover Magazine and other experts. …

On Friday, some observers argued it may take more information than bones to accurately identify gender.

“Sex encompasses the sum of different biological attributes, including sex chromosomes, certain genes, gametes, sex hormone levels, internal and external genitalia, other secondary sex characteristics, brain neurology and gender,” said one Twitter user wrote.

“Those attributes are not always aligned.”

Worth reading in full.

Subscribe
Notify of

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

19 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
NeilParkin
3 years ago

I am long past the point where I can be bothered to raise an eyebrow at this nonsense.

JXB
JXB
3 years ago

“Sex encompasses the sum of different biological attributes, including sex chromosomes, certain genes, gametes, sex hormone levels…’

Sex is not the sum of anything. It is determined at the moment of conception, according to whether a Y chromosome, or X chromosome bearing sperm penetrates the ovum.

This then determines whether ovaries or testes will develop in the fœtus and this determines hormone output and this affects the skeleton, such as size of attachment points for muscle/ligaments (bigger in men), pelvic shape, length of long-bones (longer/thicker in men), shape of facial bones.

It is basic anatomy.

Peter W
Peter W
3 years ago
Reply to  JXB

You’re being sexist now!

Mogwai
3 years ago

Bloody hellfire! Is there no end to this insanity?? 😮 And if they start rebranding my handbag staple, Fisherman’s Friends, then I’ll really kick off.

https://odysee.com/@Bob:2/VID_20230306_070847_700:c

godknowsimgood
godknowsimgood
3 years ago
Reply to  Mogwai

They’re in the process of rebranding, in consultation with Sam Smith, they’re now going to be called Fisherthem’s Friends.

Mogwai
3 years ago
Reply to  godknowsimgood

Well I’m sure Fisherwomen the world over will breathe a themtol-heavy sigh of relief. After so many years of oppression, how could they not? Especially at the sugar-free variety…

transmissionofflame
3 years ago

There are interesting implications for criminal forensics.

ebygum
3 years ago

I can’t help myself now…whenever I read any article I wonder who the people are and what is their agenda…..?
Besides the fact that Yearwood sounds utterly stupid…I looked up the ‘Discover Magazine’ item…that takes you to an article by a PHD student called Alexandra Kralick…whose bio states…..
“She developed a novel holistic methodology to identify the morphology, maturation, and ecology of two different types of adult male orangutans, flanged and unflanged, in museum collections. Using an osteobiographic approach, she brings fresh revelations to old museum collections. Her work pushes disciplinary boundaries by engaging with queer and feminist theory to showcase how great ape skeletons defy normative assumptions of biological sex and gender. Her work has been generously supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF) and Leakey Foundation.”

So no agenda there then!!?LOL! As for the ‘other’ experts..it sounds like they just mis labelled some skeletons..or weren’t sure…so if in doubt they MUST be intersex, according to Alexandra…..

A load of baloney…..and it makes me happy that the students actually laughed at him….

disgruntled246
disgruntled246
3 years ago
Reply to  ebygum

That’s quite some word salad in Kralick’s bio.

AynRandyAndy
3 years ago

If you were to dig up Gabby Yearwood and another human – a hundred years from now, there’d be no problem identifying which one was the bell-end.

Mogwai
3 years ago

Well gotta love this story and I wonder if the good doctor would be able to tell these competitors’ skeletons apart…Team Canada’s 100% male powerlifting coach entered the women’s competition identifying as female. He didn’t even bother to shave his beard off let alone paint his nails! And he beat the previous Trans record holder/imposter to boot! Great to see real men standing alongside women and supporting them in calling out this blatant attack on women’s sports, as opposed to snidey, misogynist, arse-weasels who think this assault on females’ identity and equal rights is all women’s fault in the first place! ”One of those who considered it to be the wrong choice was definitely Avi Silverberg, team Canada’s powerlifting coach. Avi surprised the world by entering a powerlifting competition as a woman, despite very evidently being a biological male. Additionally, Avi also managed to break the Women’s Bench Press Record with a lift of 167.5 kilograms (369.3 pounds). Avi Silverberg completed this feat at the 2023 Heroes Classic on February 25th, in Lethbridge, Alberta. This competition was sanctioned by CPU (Canadian Powerlifting Union), which has a pretty straightforward policy regarding self-identification. It states that anyone who refers to themselves as a woman can… Read more »

ebygum
3 years ago
Reply to  Mogwai

Hahaha…love it Mogs…just too many women give in under pressure….I’m with you all the way…
Good on Avi as well!!

Mogwai
3 years ago
Reply to  ebygum

Think if I was attempting to bench press double my bodyweight I’d be giving in under pressure too!😵💪

Trev the Geek
3 years ago
Reply to  Mogwai

He didn’t even bother to shave his beard off let alone paint his nails! And he beat the previous Trans record holder/imposter to boot! Great to see real men standing alongside women and supporting them in calling out this blatant attack on women’s sports, as opposed to snidey, misogynist, arse-weasels…

You make me laugh Mogs. 🤣🤣

Mogwai
3 years ago
Reply to  Trev the Geek

😁 Well it doesn’t do to be serious all the time. I just tend to blurt out my thoughts via my fingertips, is all.👍

DevonBlueBoy
DevonBlueBoy
3 years ago
Reply to  Mogwai

And we’re all the happier for it 👍

Peter W
Peter W
3 years ago

Well that’s a definitive end to sexing a skeleton (he must be right as he’s a professor). Could be a problem in police investigation and archeology. I always thought that there was a difference in the shape of hips between male and female but then if there is no male or female then it doesn’t matter!
What a pratt.

GMO
GMO
3 years ago

Men have xy chromosomes.
Women have XX chronosomes.

Has that changed?

The Real Engineer
The Real Engineer
3 years ago

He needs to explain how the male ones can possibly have babies, I suggest the insertion of a baby sized piece of wood into his (can that be right now?) pelvis without anesthetic to demonstrate the effect. I expect a suitable opening can be found!