Primary School Pupils Up to Six Months Behind in Maths Because of Lockdown
After just the first lockdown, data suggest that average primary school pupils in England were 3.6 months behind the level in maths that pre-pandemic years had achieved at the same stage, rising to almost six months in Yorkshire and the Humber. The Telegraph has more.
In normal times, there is a shocking poverty gap when it comes to how our children do at school. By the time they arrive for their very first day, disadvantaged kids are already four months’ learning behind their more privileged peers. Yet these are not normal times. Two years of Covid shutdowns have led to educational consequences that grimly rival those of a deprived upbringing – but for all.
After the first lockdown, for example, the latest data suggests average primary school pupils were 3.6 months adrift of the level in maths that pre-pandemic years had achieved at the same stage. Children in some parts of the country fared far worse. In Yorkshire and the Humber, the gap was 5.7 months. When it came to reading, primary children unlucky enough to find themselves in the Covid cohort were on average just under two months behind.
The question now for teachers, parents and the Government is whether they will ever catch up, or whether the years of disruption they have encountered today will cascade through the rest of their lives, impacting university and career prospects and their personal lives, too.
It was never meant to be like this. But temporary emergency measures have morphed into a two-year trial, with repeated lockdowns, homeschooling, and the pingdemic puncturing entire class bubbles. Still, it goes on.
In January, almost one in 12 teachers was off work. Last week, MPs declared the Government’s £5 billion National Tutoring Programme to help disadvantaged children ‘level up’ after Covid to be a costly failure. Meanwhile, according to the Centre for Social Justice, 100,000 “ghost children” – those who miss more than half their school sessions – have almost entirely disappeared from education since last year’s return to schools.
Making good will not be easy. Deprived children may start school only four months behind, but generally they don’t catch up. According to Natalie Perera, CEO of the Education Policy Institute (EPI), by the time they leave education, the gap has widened to 18 months. So will Britain’s Covid cohort suffer a similar fate? …
Repeated lockdowns are likely to take a significant toll on young people’s physical health given that, in 2019, a study suggested that people were 6.85% less likely to report poor health in later life for one additional year of schooling.
Meanwhile, surveyed by the charity Young Minds, two-thirds of children said they expected repeated lockdowns to leave long-term scars on their mental health. This is borne out by teachers who have seen children regress, not just in their studies, but in their social behaviour. Suddenly, the function of classrooms not just as places of learning, but of pastoral care, has become all too evident.
Many places saw a rise in children referred to social services. In Middlesbrough, the number rose by 40% year on year. As Amanda Spielman, Ofsted’s Chief Inspector, wrote in her recent annual report: “This was a difficult year to be young, and a challenging time to be learning. In all phases of education in 2020/21, most children and young people have learned less than they normally would have done. For many, the loss of education, disrupted routine and lack of physical and other activities led to physical and mental health problems. Loneliness, boredom and misery became endemic among the young.”
Worth reading in full.
To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.
Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.
I reckon my two kids are at least a year ahead of where they would have been even if the schools had never closed – because they’re now home educated.
IXL.com for Mathematics relieves us of the chore of marking, leaving us free to focus our energies on understanding why they make any mistakes.
Duolingo and travel for languages.
“Simply Piano”, an app for teaching piano, while no replacement for a proper teacher, is truly excellent.
Local gymnastics for their fitness.
Lessons in history and critical thinking inspired by the last two years of democide.
Do we get any financial help with any of this, now that we are not costing the LEA in the usual way? You guessed it.
And I should add: seeing their parents getting very angry about the things which are happening, seeing us explain why we are so angry, and then apologising for being so angry, has helped their mental health and helped us respect each other all the more.
Being surrounded by so many in masks has taught us all to recognise, cope with and reduce feelings of contempt for our fellows.
Every day is a ‘school day’.
Interesting.
My year 5 and year 10 boys are both (light) years ahead of where the average kids are. But then me and the wife are very “High Functioning” ( and the wife is a schoolteacher anyway at the school they go to! )
Maths English all way ahead.
My year 5 boy learns nothing academic at school but can wax lyrical on history and geopolitics. He has a vocabulary greater than most of his teachers The year 10 boy is a “Straight A” student.
We do a hybrid of homelearning of useful skills like finance, business, emotional intelligence, street smarts, geopolitics, critical thinking etc
The thing the boys learn at school is how to pretend to fit in, and cope with the dullards, and some more street smarts too.
God help the kids with “Normies” for parents.
Yeah. The way I always viewed schools (especially so, these days) is the same way my father taught me to view Military Conscription: while the popular narrative is that it “makes men from boys”, the reality is that the nasty blokes learn to be nastier and the good guys get depressed. It very rarely makes them “men” and they certainly don’t learn much about how to fight.
PS I saw many a Trabant in Czechoslovakia since my first visit in 1991 when I was nobbutalad. Many are still going!
Interesting perspective.
My father was in the ( American) air force and uncle in the (British ) army, but neither of them ever talked about it 🤦♂️ ( and both sadly passed now ) I guess they were of the generation that stayed tight lipped.
Certainly not an exact parallel, but in that direction!
Tight lipped… “real men” didn’t talk about their inner worlds… sad, they could perhaps have passed on so much more wisdom.
‘nobbutalad’ ? Or is that just a typo for ‘demobbed’ ?
Haha! Shorthand for “nowt but a laddie”
Ta, new one for my lexicon.
Repeat of my comment to MAk, about your own commitment, above.
Reads like your ongoing commitment is just as important for your children’s advancement as the decision about homeschooling.
Those with less committed parents may not fare so well.
I would advise your children not to “show off” their advancement as this could inspire jealousy and ridicule from their peers.
Very true
My boys are pretty good at hiding their light under a bushel. Not showoffy at all.
Of course. That, in itself, is a lesson. See my comment above about contempt.
the image above makes me sad really as it looks like safetyism run-amok.
Look on the bright side – two children not muzzled.
and they look bored 🙂
Yeah, but at least they (the two unmuzzled) are awake.
As for the rest, it’s hard to tell.
I wonder what country it is? The characters at top are Chinese.
It’s how I looked in every maths lesson, minus the muzzle of course.
Me too. The lessons seemed to be rarely about maths, and more about how to remember certain formats of questions we would see in tests. Abysmal.
These days, the school has “specialist science and maths status”. I take my kids there on Saturdays for samba squad. The place is still covered with signs for masks, 2m distancing… and information about mental illness. Sickening.
My history lessons consisted of being given a book and a set of questions on a piece of paper. The ‘lesson’ was to find the answers in the book to the questions on the paper. There was never any proper input from the so-called teacher. I consider pretty much the whole of my education as inadequate.
My wife is reading “Deschooling Society” by Ivan Ilyich. There’re so many brilliant points in there.
I’ll have a look for that.
I – Spy then 😀
I might be able to manage that 🙂
A few decades ago maths textbooks assumed all children were middle class; setting questions based on many Rods were in a cricket wicket ot how many furlongs in the Grand National.
These days they assume kids are fully up to speed with Political Correctness which will already be out of date before the books even reach the classroom or computer screen.
It word be bad enough if it “worked”.
To be honest…
Looking at the title image for this article..
I couldn’t give a damn about maths.
It’s the least problem.
The moment I see numbers and/or a graph, my mind becomes as blank as that of a covidian cultist. Maths was never my forte.
I have to agree. Both swedenborg and Freecumbria post clearly well researched work but I am afraid it bores me. I salute their efforts but my brain does not follow it.
Furthermore our current situation has F. all to do with a bloody virus.
Each to his own huxy, maths was bored out of me at school, except brong able to check my change, but it fascinates and informs others.
Exactly. The ability to quantify your surroundings is crucial to so many endeavours, and I find it hard to forgive my secondary school for the way they approached the teaching of it.
I have more positive memories of my primary school. In particular, the memory of one lady, Mrs Sen, who was Russian. She was the first to tell me I had given a wrong answer. It was so calming. Suddenly here was someone who wanted to help me understand and wasn’t bothered about the fact I didn’t yet understand. She was honest. She was not patronising. She wasn’t indoctrinated to believe that “it’s bad to tell children they’ve got something wrong.” She didn’t last long, sadly.
Are we now expected to hate Mrs. Sen retrospectively ?
To your main point about quantifying your surroundings.
I enjoy geography and history because I am surrounded by it all the time. Having some knowledge about how things around me got to where they are is most rewarding.
Think you have misunderstood me, karenovirus. Mrs Sen was excellent!
This is a great book
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innumeracy_(book)
That brings numbers and their practical application to life
Does it explain what simultaneous equations can do for me ?
My dad was teaching me trigonometry and multilateral equations (or somesuch) until I asked him what they were for.
Lol I literally used trigonometry pretty much for the first time ever recently ( after leaving school 36 years ago ) to calculate the total height of my soon to be installed ( DIY ) in-garden solar array!
I disagree with Will Jungs’ final assessment
It’s only 100 years since childhood fulltime education became universal. How did humanity progress before then ?
Exactly. The authorities want everyone to believe that teaching our children is some massively complicated dark art which requires the experts. A bit like they want everyone to believe that our own health is something best left to the experts.
Most people can’t afford to teach their own children because they’re too busy chasing mountains of mortgage, often incurred in the name of living near “a good school”.
Seeing that picture is horrible, I truly hope it’s not a UK school.
Teachers could still smack when I was at primary, and I fell foul of that on a couple of occasions. Who knows, I might have deserved my couple of incidents but I came out roughly okay.
For me, the true abuse is the tiny yellow cubicles – horrific!
My immediate thought was that it was in China.
Probably in Soho, London.
Is it racist to suggest the pupils “look Chinese”.
Bound to be
My son is torn between home educating his children and sending them to their local indoctrination centre where they are instructed to believe that men can have babies, men who put a dress on become women, there are 100 plus genders, cow farts cause sea level rise, ‘we’ won ‘the war’, White people are racist, men landed on the moon, nation state is bad/open borders good, Islam is a religion of peace, mass migration gives rise to social cohesion, all cultures are equal, the curriculum needs de-colonising, only Black Lives Matter, a hidden elite do not control the world, a new virus killed 18 million people and only the WHO and Bill Gates saved humanity. And this is just for starters.
If children who later grow into adults do not accept all this as true, and force others to accept it as true, they are ejected by the system.
Like Putin said, the West is an Empire of Lies.
Chinese students at our University do not want to know how to learn, they just want to know The Answer.
Good look with that when they enter the big wide world.
These schools have our kids for 11 years and still most leave with maths skills you could learn playing darts. Our education system is not fit for purpose. My lad left at 12 and did his English gcse at college before his year had left. Now runs his own business.
Richard Branson much the same I believe and wotsisname called his pubs Weatherspoons in memory of his teacher who said he would never achieve anything.
Whilst my grandchildren seem not to have suffered too much, mainly because their parents have made great efforts to keep things as “normal” as possible for them, it’s really not possible to tell what emotions, complexes and other things resulting from all of this, and not just school/education, may be lurking beneath the surface, to come to light in later years.
What really brasses me off is the mantra and excuse, trotted out so often by so many, that children are “resilient”. They aren’t an amorphous mass, and some may be able to cope with something whilst others cannot. I think it’s down to being an “individual”.
Individual? That’s a baaad thing.
The mono-maniacal “scientists” and Johnson’s cowardly Government have wrecked the life chances of a whole generation of children.
Our children already struggled with maths due to a lack of decent maths teachers …. yet they were sent to be home schooled by parents who, in many cases, were completely incapable of teaching maths due to their own innumeracy.
If you have a child, and the resources, pay for a maths tutor. Otherwise they will never catch up.
My granddaughter progressed because she was home schooled during the closures, her dad is a primary school teacher. The school where he teaches is in one of the poorer areas of Sheffield, and I think the pupils there regressed. Trying to teach remotely may work for the more able, wealthier and older children but fails miserably for the less able or poorer families, due to lack of incentive and the requisite technology. Primary aged children need the social environment that school provides as much as the learning itself. Home schooling may work if you live in a house with a garden but it doesn’t if you are living on the top floor of a tower block.
We don’t have a garden. They play in the streets and the local park. We’ve let them both go out without us, together, since ages 7 and 9.
No, we don’t live in some leafy Burford, or a Laurie Lee Slad.
And I do get your point. Life just isn’t fair, and there’s no point trying to hide that fact from our children.
Kids Fight Back: The theme for British Science Week 2022 poster competition is ‘Growth’. My 9 year old has submitted his; two themes, knowledge and science is always growing such that 1. the last two years will be a gold mine for future scientists like the kids of today to bust your fakery; and 2. as knowledge and growth is always growing “nothing in science is ever settled”. “The theme is growth. Knowledge and science itself are always growing; in science nothing is ever settled. Ancient people believed the Earth was flat. It is how it appears to us, and if people travelled too far in one direction and were not seen again, it was a reason to believe they fell off the edge of the Earth. While the theory that the Earth is not flat but rather a globe was first proposed by Pythagoras around 500 BCE, it took over two thousand years for Magellan’s expedition (1522) to circumnavigate the world for people to start to believe it. The last two years around the world have been yet another example of growth in knowledge. The story of the last two years and the role science played in it, will provide… Read more »
The schoolteachers’ unions are more of a threat to our children than little Mr Putin.
A group of us discussed this and predicted almost exactly what they have now found. As a result I looked at what was needed to repair the cost of lockup in education. Basically it was something like the entire education budget. Because there is no cheap way to do it, because there just aren’t the teachers to do it, and the children who need it most, are already struggling.
In fact, the worst thing, was that it was quite obvious that middle class parents (i.e. MPs & civil servants) would game the system ensure almost all the money went to benefit their darling brats, and that almost none would eventually get to the children whose education they ruined.
This should give them a head start in years to come when they apply for jobs in mathematical modelling.
From which area of the world is the photo of these children being emotionally and psychologically damaged? Doesn’t appear to be Britain.