Zero-Covid Disaster Continues as New Zealand Extends its Lockdown and Sydney Places Residents Under House Arrest Until October

Advocates of zero-Covid have a lot to answer for. New Zealand PM Jacinda Arden has just announced that the three-day lockdown imposed earlier this week in response to one coronavirus case – you read that correctly – is being extended for a week, following a rise in positive test results to a whopping 31. Meanwhile, Gladys Berejiklian, the Premier of New South Wales, announced that Sydney would remain in lockdown until the end of September. In certain parts of the city, a 9pm to 5am curfew will be imposed and outside exercise restricted to one hour a day. New Zealand has seen only 26 Covid deaths in a population of five million, while Australia has chalked up 974 in a population of over 25 million – yet the insane zero-Covid policy means just one positive case can prompt a lockdown, as we saw in New Zealand earlier this week. MailOnline has more.

Ardern, who is trying to sustain a zero-Covid strategy through strict border controls and lockdowns, initially announced the national shutdown would last three days but on Friday had to succumb to the inevitable and extend it to at least a week.

Vast swathes of Australia are also under zero-Covid lockdowns and residents of Sydney were told they will have to stay home until at least October under strict lockdown rules that will not be lifted until at least 70% of the population are fully vaccinated.

When it hits that vaccination target, the restrictions will be lifted under a “freedom roadmap” similar to the one implemented in the U.K. months ago.

New Zealand initially brought in its lockdown over one case but Ardern said that officials were still trying to assess the scale of the outbreak, which emerged in Auckland this week and has now spread to Wellington.

“We just don’t quite know the full scale of this Delta outbreak. All in all, this tells us we need to continue to be cautious,” she said.

Worth reading in full.

Daily Sceptic contributor Ramesh Thakur, Emeritus Professor at the Crawford School of Public Policy at the Australian National University, has an excellent piece about Australia’s descent into an authoritarian dystopia in the Japan Times. Here’s an extract:

Australia has morphed from being the envy of the world last year for its incredible pandemic management to international incredulity at the brutality of its authoritarian measures to “crush and kill the virus”.

In America, popular conservative TV host Tucker Carlson calls Australia a “COVID dictatorship”. With unconscious irony, the video clip was removed from YouTube. His colleague Laura Ingraham was incredulous at learning that soldiers and police helicopters were patrolling Sydney’s streets and skies to enforce the lockdown.

The premier of Australia’s largest state said on Aug. 14th, at a time when the Taliban were making lightning advances across Afghanistan, that this current pandemic is “literally a war”. The U.K. Telegraph said in an editorial, “How has it come to the point that Australia needs to call up the military to eradicate a virus that is now endemic in the world?”

Beijing is enjoying a moment of schadenfreude. In an article in Global Times, the mouthpiece of the Chinese Communist Party, Lu Xue recalled comments from Foreign Minister Marise Payne that were critical of China’s aggressive pandemic management. “Some countries,” she said in June 2020, “are using the pandemic to undermine liberal democracy to promote their own more authoritarian models.” Lu added, “Now, quite ironically, it turns out that Canberra plans to send its military personnel to help enforce social lockdown.”

The authoritarian streak has seen various instances of what some people would call inhumane treatment. At a time of zero active cases in Canberra, a woman was denied permission to fly to Queensland to see her dying father. A mother from across the border in New South Wales lost her baby last year after being unable to get timely treatment in Brisbane because of the time it would have taken to fill out the paperwork to cross the state line and enter the hospital to receive emergency care.

A fully vaccinated Sydney grandmother was also recently denied a permit to go to Melbourne to help care for her grandchildren while her daughter battles advanced breast cancer. And in a country town in February, a pregnant woman posting on Facebook to support a peaceful protest against Victoria’s lockdown was handcuffed and arrested in her house in the early morning hours, still in her pajamas.

Worth reading in full.

Subscribe
Notify of

To join in with the discussion please make a donation to The Daily Sceptic.

Profanity and abuse will be removed and may lead to a permanent ban.

55 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
steve_z
4 years ago

We need full economic sanctions against Australia and New Zealand.

Annie
4 years ago
Reply to  steve_z

What good would that do?

Moist Von Lipwig
4 years ago
Reply to  steve_z

They are imposing sanctions on themselves.

me too
me too
4 years ago

Who pays politics salaries?

Moist Von Lipwig
4 years ago
Reply to  me too

What are you gibbering about?

me too
me too
4 years ago
Reply to  steve_z

Several governments are ending, slowly, with sanctions and curfews. The stupid “chiefs” are now realizing that with no money (people are getting poorer) there will be no taxes payment. As simple as that.

Lockdown Sceptic
4 years ago
Reply to  steve_z

The Western World is being deliberately destroyed

They’ve Destroyed My High StreetGame Over Right???
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Sd4A1IebcE

Stand in South Hill Park Bracknell every Sunday from 10am meet fellow anti lockdown freedom lovers, keep yourself sane, make new friends and have a laugh.

Join our Stand in the Park – Bracknell – Telegram Group
http://t.me/astandintheparkbracknell

Just Stop it Now
4 years ago

Enough! We get it LS….you have a SiTP in Bracknell and good for you, its an excellent movement. There are STIPs in parks throughout the UK.

But I’m guessing the majority of us are not local to Bracknell so it is of zero interest. Please do us a favour and take it out of your posts, it’s tiresome and detracts from your message

Peter W
Peter W
4 years ago

I skip the posts. Fed up of them!

OnceIWasARemainer
OnceIWasARemainer
4 years ago

Or post a note of it maximum of once per two days or something, that will give any newly converted sceptics in Bracknell a good enough chance of seeing it.

Gregoryno6
4 years ago
Reply to  steve_z

Why bother? Our own governments are fucking us up better than anyone else could do it.

OnceIWasARemainer
OnceIWasARemainer
4 years ago
Reply to  steve_z

I think invading them on ground of protecting the human rights of their citizens, oops typo there, “citizens” should be spelled “victims”, from a violent and repressive regime. An Operation Australi Freedom you might say. Also, with troops busy harassing the population, they’ve less soldiers to resist the intervention of any foreign country who marches in to help restore democracy in those benighted nations.

HelenaHancart
HelenaHancart
4 years ago

When I saw Jacinda Ahern’s name pop up in an old conspiracy theory book I have, from 15 years ago, where it was announced that she was being primed as a Young Global Leader, to bring about huge global changes in 2020(!) you KNOW this ain’t about a virus! But…thats just a conspiracy theory, don’t you know? Thoughts go out my fellow human beings in those places. No doubt they’re going to try thrashing us again in the autumn/winter.

Trojan House
Trojan House
4 years ago
Reply to  HelenaHancart

What’s the name of the book?

HelenaHancart
HelenaHancart
4 years ago
Reply to  Trojan House

It was The Rough Guide to Conspiracy Theories. I have to make a correction to my above post. The book didn’t actually state Jacinda Ahern’s name but it invites you to follow information, which is where I discovered her as being listed…along with a few other prominent names, on the Young Global Leaders website at that time!

lorrinet
lorrinet
4 years ago
Reply to  HelenaHancart

Sounds like Common Purpose. Many of our leaders have been indoctrinated with it, and the spread of this malign philosophy is like a virus itself. What a pity is doesn’t kill its host.

OnceIWasARemainer
OnceIWasARemainer
4 years ago
Reply to  lorrinet

Successful viruses don’t kill their hosts. That’s why covid is spreading so well, barely ever klls. Although of course if you brutally isolate the mild cases but take the bad oens to hospital then you place an evolutionary pressure against the usual ways of viruses and can start pushing a virus to get deadlier.

Trojan House
Trojan House
4 years ago

And the people in those countries take it like the sheep that they are. I thought Aussies and Kiwis were a strong bunch. Turns out I was wrong.

Fingerache Philip
Fingerache Philip
4 years ago
Reply to  Trojan House

Amongst the English speaking world, only parts of the USA are showing any resistance to this madness, as far as I can make out.

Trojan House
Trojan House
4 years ago

Yes, even here in Canada, Quebecers are protesting the implementation of vaxpassports in that province! Otherwise, nothing in the rest of English Canada.

iane
iane
4 years ago
Reply to  Trojan House

Yes I used to think that that old saw about more sheep than humans only applied to New Zealand. If there is an all-powerful, all-knowing god, then surely it is past time to put a stop to all this insanity.

iane
iane
4 years ago

Such appallingly shocking stories about the level of inhumanity down-under. Even Hancock, if he were ever let off the leash, would find it hard to exceed this type of dictatorial control.

Moist Von Lipwig
4 years ago
Reply to  iane

He would most certainly try, nonetheless….

grob1234
grob1234
4 years ago

I genuinely don’t wish the people of NZ and Aus any harm, because they’re beautiful countries full of good people.

However….

I hope and pray that these zero covid policies are a total flop, both in terms of controlling the virus, and the economic outcome. And my word am I ever pleased to have a totally incomptent government here in the UK, as oppose to the shambles in the southern hemisphere.

OnceIWasARemainer
OnceIWasARemainer
4 years ago
Reply to  grob1234

I pray and hope they get invaded by a real democracy, like Sweden, or an independent state of Florida, before thei leaders can cause them to become even mroe terrible flops than they already are.

DanClarke
DanClarke
4 years ago

Its interesting to read The New Zealand Herald, how the media play off countries against each other. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/covid-19-coronavirus-what-happened-after-the-uk-dropped-all-restrictions/BP56KK2VNDVZNGGG73FFMTUS6U/

RW
RW
4 years ago
Reply to  DanClarke

The interesting thing is that they’re trying to spin this as disaster very hard while almost completely failing to mention all the wrong predictions of imminent apocalypse. Eg,

Kit Yates, co-director of the Centre for Mathematical Biology at the University of Bath, told CNN countries like Australia should be careful about following the UK strategy blindly.
“If there was one lesson I wish other countries would take from watching the UK’s attempt to reopen is that vaccines are not the whole solution to the problem,” Yates said.

The wording is already loaded and incorrect: England (not the UK) didn’t make an (ultimatively abandoned, as this suggests) attempt to reopen, it reopened. Now, four weeks later, while there has been a moderate rebound in the numbers of positive test results, both the abolute number and the growth of it remains solidly below the level from before reopening. If there’s something to be learned from that, it would be mask mandates make no difference. And neither does enforced separation of patrons in pubs nor enforced closure of night clubs.

peyrole
peyrole
4 years ago

And still at least 50% of the populations of these countries support this.

RTSC
RTSC
4 years ago

Glad I never emigrated …. dodged a disaster there.

MTF
MTF
4 years ago

Surely the whole justification of the NZ/Aus strategy is that you can avoid much worse disruption later by coming down hard when the epidemic shows first signs? This strategy may prove to be wrong but it is silly to criticise them for locking down for very few cases – that’s the whole idea.

BoycottEuropeanEmpire
BoycottEuropeanEmpire
4 years ago
Reply to  MTF

That might have been justified last year when little was known about the virus, but not now.

There is no proper cost/benefit analysis (true also of UK and many countries, to be fair).

There is widespread inhumanity and abuse of power.

Their vaccination programs are slow, backward and lame (just like their cretinous putative ‘leaders’).

The whole implied endeavour of ‘covid eradication’ is pointless anyway, given the endemic presence of many variants globally.

So massive criticism of sick, pompous authoritarians like Arden is absolutely correct.

Moist Von Lipwig
4 years ago
Reply to  MTF

There is no justification for lockdown.

jonathan Palmer
jonathan Palmer
4 years ago
Reply to  MTF

What a stupid argument.I feel I’ve been transported back a year.
So you lock down hard to prevent locking down hard later.
Zero COVID is lunacy but it’s not about a virus,it’s about bringing in a control grid so the economy can be reset.
Australian and New Zealand politicians are just following the same orders as European leaders but their seasons are the opposite so they have to use different justifications.

MTF
MTF
4 years ago
Reply to  MTF

I want to make this clearer. My point was that the article above suggests that the NZ lockdown was a disproportionate response to the number of cases. But the whole idea behind the NZ strategy is that you don’t respond to the number of cases – by then it is too late – you react to the first sign of an outbreak to prevent it becoming a large number of cases – just as you would for say foot and mouth disease amongst cattle. That way the intervention can be hard but short. Of course for many here it is pretty much a given that lockdowns never work, but it is hard to explain why else NZ was able to suppress the epidemic so quickly in 2020. My theory is that lockdowns work well when the outbreak is in its early stages but usually governments (understandably) wait until it is rampant when things such as herd immunity and behavioural reaction to the outbreak are more important and may well have already started to bring the outbreak under control. Assuming that early lockdowns do suppress outbreaks, is this a good strategy? It seemed to work well last year. NZ had negative… Read more »

OnceIWasARemainer
OnceIWasARemainer
4 years ago
Reply to  MTF

Actually, locking down for the first few known cases is still very silly, by the time you know about one case there are already hundreds and they have all spread it to thousands more, and lockdowns won’t stop the spread however rare the virus is. Locking down “early” is always too late, and lockdowns don’t ever work anyway.

MTF
MTF
4 years ago

NZ reached about 60 to 70 cases a day in April 2020 and then it dropped to effectively nothing and has stayed that way ever since. It seems the lockdown was not too late. Or do you have other suggestions as to why that epidemic never took off?

RW
RW
4 years ago
Reply to  MTF

This strategy has been proven wrong, because even despite the augurs were convinced that New Zealand, being a small, sparsely populated island at the end of the world must be ideally suited to try this, it didn’t work there: After over a year, they’re still trying to suppress an illness which keeps flaring up nevertheless.

Obviously, this just means they have to be more radical: Handle it like foot & mouth disease: If there’s an infection in Wellingtion, cull the population. Anything short of that is just a half-hearted measure.

MTF
MTF
4 years ago
Reply to  RW

NZ have had a total of less than 3,000 cases since the epidemic began. We are currently getting 30,000 a day. To describe this as “still trying suppress the illness” is imaginative to say the least. Their strategy accepts and deals with an occasional flare up and this is dealt with at the moment by a short sharp lockdown.

Has it occurred to you that if the Oxford Ivermectin trial is as successful as presumably you expect, then NZ will be laughing? They will be able to use Ivermectin to deal with the virus having had a tiny fraction of the deaths, lower all cause excess mortality, a better economy and on average far more freedom than any other advanced nation.

BoycottEuropeanEmpire
BoycottEuropeanEmpire
4 years ago

A few years ago, when I was thinking about living abroad, I wondered what it would be like to live in Australia or New Zealand.

Now I know.

Dodged a massive bullet there.

Lockdown Sceptic
4 years ago

The Western World is being deliberately destroyed

They’ve Destroyed My High StreetGame Over Right???
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Sd4A1IebcE

Stand in South Hill Park Bracknell every Sunday from 10am meet fellow anti lockdown freedom lovers, keep yourself sane, make new friends and have a laugh.

Join our Stand in the Park – Bracknell – Telegram Group
http://t.me/astandintheparkbracknell

Emerald Fox
4 years ago

I went to Bracknell once. It was awful.

stewart
4 years ago

A zero covid policy is obviously a dumb thing. But, I’m not sure we can be all that smug here in the UK. Government actions in AUS and NZ are at least consistent with their strategy.

What the hell are we doing in the UK (and other western countries)? Our governments seem to acknowledge that this new virus is endemic and most of the population has been jabbed with a treatment they tell us works. And yet we continue to have all kinds of measures in place, travel restrictions, tests, quarantines, masks. What for? They don’t even have the excuse that hospitals are full.

At least down under they are logical and consistent. And btw, they’re just doing what we had done to us before – nasty, dehumanising lockdowns.

Emerald Fox
4 years ago
Reply to  stewart

“And yet we continue to have all kinds of measures in place, travel restrictions, tests, quarantines, masks. What for?”

For making money. Faisal of Halifax knows:

https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/news/west-yorkshire-news/halifax-covid-test-firm-furious-21092153

helenf
4 years ago
Reply to  stewart

Aiming for zero covid is as bat-shit crazy as aiming for zero flu. But of course it’s not about a virus, and I don’t believe it ever was. All around the world we see examples of governments seeing what they can “get away with”, to quote our own bought and paid for sociopath/ useful idiot, Neil Ferguson.

AethelredTheReadier
AethelredTheReadier
4 years ago
Reply to  stewart

I don’t remember any curfews nor of any restrictions on movement in the UK. Also, we can choose not to wear masks now even though there are many who still do use them.The Australian response is ‘out of this world’ insane for so few ‘cases’ (which may be false positives anyway due to the way in which PCRs are used). Logical and consistent? There is no logic in insanity. It’s out of control but there doesn’t seem to be any push back whatsoever. I do wonder if these countries are the ‘petri dish’ for introducing harsher measures here though. You know – see how far you push a people.

stewart
4 years ago

Rational doesn’t mean good or desirable.

if you want to have zero COVID, then an extreme radical response to a single case is not only rational. It is the most rational approach. Because it’s easier to stop it at 1 than stop it at 100 let alone 1000.

The Nazi’s took a ver rational approach to the “jewish problem”. Once they decided to try to get rid of all Jews, they very rationally developed the most efficient extermination process they could come up with. It was a monstrosity but it was rational based on their goal.

The NZ and AUS governments are acting rationally in pursuit of a monstrous objective. They need to be criticised for the correct thing which is that they are inhumane, totalitarian population abusers.

flyingjohn
4 years ago

Australia is over. It is now a Police State, shut off from the world with Martial Law.

And Australia citizens deserve it. They have allowed their country to become North Korea. We were planning to visit family this year. We will never go there again, ever. The country is lost.

Gregoryno6
4 years ago
Reply to  flyingjohn

You’re wrong.
I hope.

Emerald Fox
4 years ago
Reply to  flyingjohn

Australia and New Zealand are just territories of China now. Horse-teeth and the Australian bint with the big nose are just stooges for Xi Jinping.

Leah L
Leah L
4 years ago

Just sad beyond belief

OnceIWasARemainer
OnceIWasARemainer
4 years ago

One thing that does concern me is how little sign of protest there has been in NZ.

misslawbore
misslawbore
4 years ago

There are a lot of sheep there

MTF
MTF
4 years ago

Given that they have had lower mortality, a better economy and, on average, more freedom than almost any other advanced economy, perhaps it is not surprising.

Pavlov Bellwether
4 years ago

FIGHT. BACK. BETTER. Updated information, resources and links: https://www.LCAHub.org/

vlysander
vlysander
4 years ago

Yes how dare I sit on a bench…